A kid from New Jersey who crosses the border into New York for college pays out-of-state tuition rates. A person who crossed the border into the United States illegally does not. The Trump Department of Justice just filed suit to end that arrangement in three states, bringing the total number of federal lawsuits challenging illegal alien tuition preferences to 17.
The states getting sued this round: New York, Connecticut, and Vermont.
Assistant Attorney General Brett A. Shumate of the Justice Department's Civil Division didn't mince words. "This is a simple matter of federal law: colleges cannot provide benefits to illegal aliens that they do not" provide to citizens from other states, Shumate said. "This Department of Justice will not tolerate American students being treated like second-class citizens."
The legal argument isn't complicated. Federal law has long prohibited states from offering in-state tuition to illegal aliens unless they extend the same benefit to all U.S. citizens regardless of residency. New York, Connecticut, and Vermont have been doing it anyway — granting not just discounted tuition but in some cases financial aid to people who are in the country illegally, while families one state line over pay the full freight.
The DOJ's position, filed in the Second Circuit, leans on a straightforward reading of a statute that's been on the books for years. "Congress long ago made clear that States cannot put illegal aliens over our Nation's own citizens," said ASG Woodward. "By granting illegal aliens in-state tuition, New York, Vermont, and Connecticut are doing just that. No more."
The progressive counter-argument is predictable: these students grew up here, they graduated from local high schools, they're part of the community. Which sounds reasonable until you remember that "grew up here" doesn't change federal immigration status, and "part of the community" isn't a legal category that overrides a congressional statute. The families paying $40,000 a year in out-of-state tuition because their kid chose a school two hours from home grew up in a community too. Their community just doesn't come with a tuition waiver.
This is the kind of policy that survives only because nobody puts the two price tags next to each other. A middle-class family in Pennsylvania sends their daughter to a SUNY school and gets billed at the non-resident rate. A family that entered the country without documentation sends their kid to the same school and pays the resident rate. Same classroom. Same degree. Different bill. The only variable is which border you crossed and whether you had paperwork when you did it.
This lawsuit is part of the Trump administration's push to dismantle policies that treat illegal immigration as a non-factor in public benefit distribution. With 17 suits now filed, the DOJ has made clear this isn't a symbolic fight over one state's admissions office.
Comments are closed.