Zohran Mamdani became a United States citizen in 2018. Eight years later, as Mayor of New York City, he sat down with Charles Blow on The Root and announced that "we" — his word — need to start talking about cash reparations for descendants of enslaved people.
In the interview, Mamdani said, "Here in New York City, we were very complicit," he told Blow, leaving the door wide open for direct cash payments. From a city whose current mayor had zero connection to the country, let alone the city, when any of the history he's referencing actually happened.
New York State abolished slavery in 1827. a full 199 years ago. And it wasn't a quiet, reluctant decision either. New York sent more than 50,000 of its residents to die in the Civil War fighting to end slavery across the entire nation.
This is what happens when the reparations conversation abandons any pretense of historical accountability and becomes pure political performance. It's not about who did what to whom. It's about who can position themselves as the most aggressively sympathetic with someone else's checkbook.
The "we were very complicit" framing is particularly something. Mamdani wasn't complicit in anything that happened in New York before 2018 because Mamdani wasn't here. The New Yorkers who were here — generations of them — fought a war, passed laws, built institutions, and buried 50,000 of their sons to end the very thing he's now lecturing them about.
Critics were quick to notice the obvious problem: a man using "we" to describe events that predated his arrival by nearly two centuries. It's the political equivalent of moving into a house last Tuesday and apologizing to the neighbors for what the original owner did in 1827.
The reparations push was always going to land here eventually — in a place where the person demanding payment has less connection to the history than the people being asked to pay. The math doesn't work. The history doesn't work. The only thing that works is the politics, and only if nobody asks follow-up questions.
Comments are closed.