Continue reading "A Federal Judge Just Put a $15 Billion Price Tag on the New York Times's Credibility Problem""/>
Sunday, May 10, 2026
Breaking News

A Federal Judge Just Put a $15 Billion Price Tag on the New York Times's Credibility Problem

Fifteen billion dollars. That's the number sitting on the desk of U.S. District Judge Steven Merryday in Tampa, Florida, after he ruled this week that President Trump's defamation lawsuit against the New York Times and Penguin Random House can proceed to trial. The suit targets claims made in the 2024 book Lucky Loser, authored by Times reporters Russ Buettner and Susanne Craig, which accused Trump of committing complex tax crimes.

Judge Merryday — a George H.W. Bush appointee, for anyone keeping score — found that Trump "plausibly alleged" the reporters lacked adequate support for the accusations they published.

That's federal-judge language for: you may have made this up.

The Washington Examiner reported that while Merryday dismissed claims related to two separate newspaper articles, the core of the suit — the book itself, the tax-crime accusations, the entire foundation of Buettner and Craig's reporting — survives. The case now moves to discovery, which means the Times will have to show its work. Internal emails. Editorial decisions. Source communications. Everything that went into printing allegations of criminal conduct against a sitting president.

Discovery is where confidence goes to die. It's one thing to publish a book with a provocative title and let cable news run with the implications. It's another thing entirely to sit across from opposing counsel and explain, under oath, what exactly supported the claim that Trump committed tax crimes. Buettner and Craig wrote the words. Now they'll have to defend them with something more than reputation.

Penguin Random House, one of the largest publishers on the planet, is also named as a defendant. They printed the book. They marketed the book. They put Lucky Loser on shelves knowing what it alleged. The question a jury will eventually consider is whether anyone in that chain — reporters, editors, publishers — had adequate factual support for accusing a former and current president of criminal tax fraud.

The Times has spent years positioning itself as the institution that holds power accountable. Peter Baker, their chief White House correspondent, has built a career on that premise. The paper's editorial posture assumes its journalism is careful, sourced, and legally bulletproof. Judge Merryday just ruled that at least one major project may not have been any of those things.

The same outlet that demands transparency from every government agency in Washington is about to get a long look at its own internal process. The reporters who built careers on document-based investigative work will now have their documents investigated. The institution that insists it never publishes without rock-solid sourcing will need to produce those rocks.

Two claims were dismissed. The book wasn't. That's the detail that matters. The judge looked at the newspaper articles and said those don't clear the bar. Then he looked at the book — the flagship product, the one with the publishers and the press tour and the 300 pages of implication — and said that one stays.

$15 billion. The Times's total annual revenue is a fraction of that number. Nobody expects a payout anywhere near the ask. But the suit doesn't have to bankrupt the paper to change the math. It just has to get to discovery. It just has to put internal communications on a table in a Tampa courtroom.

That part already happened.

Like this Article? Share it!


Most Popular

Most Popular

Comments are closed.